Regional open access fiber as the telecom regional airports of the 21st century

As the U.S. continues to debate the role of public and private ownership and operation of advanced telecommunications infrastructure, a California local government official offers simple aeronautical analogy to progress beyond the debate and bring ubiquitous connectivity to nearly every American doorstep.

Just as local governments own and operate regional airports, regional open access fiber infrastructure can serve as the airports for internet service providers operating as the airlines. Like airlines that rent terminal space at airports, the ISPs would rent access to the infrastructure to deliver service to their customers.

Calaveras County, California Supervisor Jack Garamendi’s concept makes a lot of sense. Investor owned vertically integrated providers cannot afford to bring fiber connections serve all homes, businesses and institutions in their nominal service areas. That’s because their investors expect relatively short term returns on capital investments incompatible with the long term investment horizon for infrastructure. Hence, the nation is handicapped with partially deployed infrastructure with only about a third of all homes having access to fiber connections that should have reached nearly all of them by 2010 with better policy and planning.

Now Garamendi is working to build what amounts to a regional airport system serving 38 California counties as president of the Golden State Connect Authority (GSCA). As a joint powers authority and governmental entity, the GSCA plans to access the public bond markets to finance the fiber. That’s more patient capital that’s compatible with fiber infrastructure serviceable for decades – much like airports. California legislation enacted in 2021 appropriates continuous funding to help secure the bond debt.

The GSCA is modeling itself on and working with the State of Utah’s Telecommunication Open Infrastructure Agency (UTOPIA), a group of 11 Utah cities that joined together in 2004 to build, deploy, and operate fiber infrastructure connecting all homes and businesses.

According to Garamendi, the GSCA plans to ramp up deployment of fiber rapidly, starting with more densely settled areas. “We’ll go fast and we’ll pick up speed,” he said at an Electronic Frontier Foundation event this week.

Let’s hope so. The GSCA must avoid only partially deploying like the large corporate investor-owned telephone companies that serve limited, more densely developed areas. Great numbers of residents and small businesses in GSCA counties have coped with lack of landline connections for many years – even in not so thinly populated exurban areas at the outlying edges of metro counties, forced to rely on high cost, low value wireless services.

The GSCA won’t be able to bring fiber to every location, Garamendi noted, given some are in very remote rural areas of the Golden State. But access to patient capital will allow it to go much farther than the far less patient capital of investor-owned providers that naturally cherry pick areas conforming to their stringent rate of return and profitability standards. 

State and regional public telecom entities like UTOPIA and the GSCA offer the nation a badly needed self sustaining model to build and operate fiber networks to provide near universal service and affordable access. Such self sustaining business structures are particularly needed in the absence of coordinated, sustained federal policy and funding designed to ensure fiber connections reach all American homes and small businesses.

Regionalism isn't new for telecom infrastructure. Telephone companies were structured as interstate regional bell operating companies formed upon the divestiture of AT&T in 1982.

Just a few miles outside of town: Falling through the cracks with outdated 1950 view of U.S. residential settlement

A good problem to have: Managing the ARPA windfall in a small NC county - Carolina Public Press:

Having more GREAT grant money to expand broadband is a point of interest for Madison County, where census data shows 72.4% of residents have a broadband internet connection — significantly less than the state’s 83.4% average.

“The grants that have been awarded — other grants not connected to this — over the years have been to reach the far outstretched parts of rural counties,” Young said. “What’s left is the people close to town that weren’t close enough. The outskirts of the county have some internet, but those a few miles outside of town are still living in 1991.”

This is a basic problem in how the U.S. subsidizes advanced telecom infrastructure. It takes a binary view of residential settlement patterns as if it were still 1950 and people either lived in town or on farms while overlooking the edges of metro areas and exurbs. Housing density in these areas is higher than rural but lower than the suburbs. But it's too low for investor owned infrastructure to be profitably built and operated. As a result, they fall through the cracks and are overlooked by both the private and public sectors.

U.S. telecom subsidy policy reliant on one off grants for "broadband" bandwidth without universal service mandate

Baltimore Eyes Federal Funds for Municipal Broadband - Bloomberg:

For decades, the phone carriers and cable companies have collected billions in fees and federal funds aimed at subsidizing service to underserved areas like Johnston Square. And yet, the mission has fallen short of the goals, said Ali.“Will we be seeing the largest incumbents swoop down on state broadband offices and simply gobble up the money?” Ali said. “This is the one big shot. We cannot let history repeat itself. Otherwise we’re going to need another $65 billion in 10 years.

That would be Christopher Ali, associate professor of media studies at the University of Virginia. Ali adroitly points up a major flaw in U.S. telecommunications policy of heavily relying on one off grants to subsidize "broadband" bandwidth instead of a coordinated, unified subsidy program combined with a universal service mandate as with voice telephone service. Updated to specify a fiber to the premises (FTTP) infrastructure standard.