Sunday, July 31, 2011

Telcos propose reforming USF to subsidize legacy DSL

A half dozen first and second tier telcos including America's largest, AT&T and Verizon, are proposing to replace the existing Universal Service Fund that subsidizes switched voice service with two new subsidy programs to provide Internet connectivity in high cost areas. The proposal was made in a July 29 filing with the U.S. Federal Communications Commission.

One program would support wireline service, the Connect America Fund (CAF). The other, the Advanced Mobility/Satellite Fund, would subsidize wireless and satellite service in the least populated, highest cost areas of the nation. The CAF subsidy would be highly granular -- down to the census block level served by an existing telco central office.

The CAF is aimed at subsidizing buildout of the telcos' legacy Digital Subscriber Line (DSL) service using fiber to feed remote DSLAMs that serve premises using the existing copper cable plant. The CAF plan proposes approximating the FCC's current asynchronous minimum definition of broadband, 4 Mbs for the download side of the connection and 1 Mbs for uploads. (The CAF proposal calls for an upload speed of 768 Kbs)

The filing comes just one week after AT&T CEO Randall Stephenson declared DSL obsolete technology.
Apparently it's not for those parts of AT&T's service area where the company has opted not to invest in building out its VDSL-based U-Verse service. For those areas, legacy ADSL that offered throughput at the current FCC minimum that was state of the art technology a decade ago will have to suffice.

If these telcos had been smart and exercised even a slight degree of foresight, they would have made this proposal in the late 1990s when they first began to roll out DSL service. Or by 2000 at the latest. At that time, they clearly knew a business case couldn't be made to deploy DSL in large swaths of their service territories without some form of subsidization.

This proposal is not only tardy by a decade or more. It sets the throughput bar too low by fixing it on today's current minimum definition of broadband. With Internet bandwidth demand growing at a rapid pace to support increasingly bandwidth hungry applications -- most notably video -- today's 4 Mbs down and 1 Mbs up standard is by definition the edge of tomorrow's obsolescence. Some would argue it's already obsolete.

The incumbent telcos' proposal also comes as community broadband projects are taking off and building out in many parts of the nation that provide far faster, future proof Internet connectivity using fiber to the premise connections.


Telecom said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Broadband said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Phone Line said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Landline said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.